During embryological development, the kidneys form in the pelvic region and normally ascend to their final position in the lumbar region. In the case of a horseshoe kidney, the lower poles of the two kidneys fuse, forming a U-shaped structure. When this fused kidney tries to ascend, it gets stopped by the inferior mesenteric artery (IMA), which arises from the aorta at the level of L3. Because the fused lower poles cannot pass beyond this vessel, the ascent halts, and the kidney remains lower than normal. This is a classic embryological point and explains why horseshoe kidneys are often found in the lower lumbar region.
Explanation of the Incorrect Options
Superior mesenteric artery (SMA)
Although the SMA is also a major branch of the abdominal aorta, it originates higher (around L1). By the time the horseshoe kidney ascends, it is already restricted by the IMA before it can reach the level of the SMA. Therefore, the SMA does not play a role in limiting ascent.
Abdominal aortic bifurcation
The aortic bifurcation into the common iliac arteries occurs at the level of L4. This point is below the origin of the IMA, so it cannot act as the barrier. In fact, if ascent were blocked here, the kidney would not even reach the lumbar region, which is not what we observe.
Urinary bladder
The bladder is located in the pelvis, and while it is related to the initial position of the developing kidneys, it does not interfere with their ascent. Once the kidneys begin migrating upward, the bladder stays behind in the pelvis, playing no role in restricting movement.
Ureter
The ureters elongate as the kidneys ascend, but they are flexible tubes that adapt to the kidney’s position. They do not mechanically restrict kidney ascent.